I'm with Arachyd on this one. Actually 'many hours of game play and fighting' is a massive understatement for some of us. If you just look at the time that I was actually sitting on a claim it was months of fighting, losing sleep, and logging in at every possible opportunity because I had to be paranoid that I might log in 10 seconds too late and lose hours worth of gold. And the attacks didn't just come in the daytime when people were on either. A lot of times enemy clans would sneak in around 3-5 am when everyone was asleep! And of course there's the money that I had to spend on supplies, potions (which were still around at that time), and warehouse slots for stored gold.
And for that matter, even working up the elections was tricky because Steel were blocking anyone who wasn't in their clan. Sure you might be thinking "Just get more fame than everyone else and you'll win!" But it wasn't that simple. If you pull too much fame out of the warehouse for a lower office the daily fame loss would tear you apart before you could even apply for sheriff's office. But if you don't pull out enough fame you'll lose the election.
And of course that's just looking at the time that I was actually sitting on a claim. There was also the trick of actually getting a claim to begin with. Naturally the first thing I had to do was convince allies that I was worthy to get a claim even though literally everyone on the server wanted one. This involved lvling up, helping others defend their stuff, ect... But that wasn't all. At that time every english clan on AM1 was crammed into 1 map, and nobody seemed too worried about changing that. And unlike every other clan on the server the english thought that it would be 'fair' to pass those those 3 claims around between everyone rather than letting anyone sit on a claim and focus on getting a rex. So for months I basically just settled for whatever fame I could get from spawn camps. Which would never have been enough. So along with Pit I led the charge into enemy territory and we ended up getting a new map. Then once we actually had some territory to work with I had to have some serious discussions with other officers to convince them that passing claims around ultimately wouldn't help anyone.
So yeah, there might be some sheriffs who got a free ride, but some of us have definitely had to earn ours.
retired sheriffs' opinions don't matter. The players who haven't been elected sheriff and unlocked the t-rex matter the most because they're the players who are going to buy gold coins and keep this game alive.
No I can't agree with this. 1) It just isn't true. I've bought gold coins after becoming sheriff, and I know Pideaux has spent a lot of money getting her stuff up to lvl 40. 2) Even if it were true, this is basically saying to kick sheriffs to the curb who have very likely already spent money on the game in favor of people who may have never spent a dime. And it won't motivate anyone to buy gold coins either. It might actually do the opposite if they can get their rex for free.
I like the suggestion but think there should be a 'stronger' t-rex for retired sheriffs to unlock at level 40 in sheriff-only elections. So Splitscreen can give away an original (2012?) t-rex once a year while the sheriffs fight for a 2014 t-rex w/ better stats than the original t-rex.
This won't work either. Not only is the value of becoming sheriff still diminished, but it would give a huge advantage to the latest sheriffs who's fame hasn't already disappeared from daily fame loss. And I don't think anyone would support a retired sheriff sitting on a claim all over again to get a stronger rex when they still don't even have a rex to begin with.